I know why the caged bird sings

Northwoods Flyer

Northwoods Flyer








…a bird that stalks down his narrow cage
can seldom see through his bars of rage…

I attended Huntsville City Councilman Will Culver’s town hall meeting, where Culver presented the City’s plan to improve pedestrian safety while crossing University Drive (40,000 vehicles per day).  Three people have been killed crossing the street, and eighteen injured, over the past ten years.  City Traffic Engineer Richard Kramer says that it is one of the most dangerous pedestrian crossings in Huntsville (West Clinton Avenue and Memorial Parkway downtown round out the top three).

Regular readers know that I like Culver – I think he has grown as a Councilman.  Culver conducted the meeting professionally, asking the audience to hold their comments for the Q&A after the presentation. Culver brought relevant City leaders to the meeting, plus Councilman Dr. Richard Showers and HHA Director Michael Lundy. About 80 or so people attended the meeting – Steve Doyle of The Huntsville Times, Eric Sollman of WAFF 48, and Chase Gallimore of WAAY 31 reported on the meeting. 

Culver’s plan was to close Yukon and Glacier Street at University, improve pedestrian crossings at Arctic and Meadow, and build a nice-looking landscaped fence along University to channel pedestrians to the improved crossings.  Culver worked with the City, State, and Huntsville Housing Authority for months developing this plan – and presented the plan at “3 or 4″ previous town halls.  Culver’s plan would cost ~$70k, much less than the two pedestrian bridges desired by residents (bridges cost ~$800k each).

Culver doesn’t want pedestrian bridges due to the City’s experience with the bridge by UAH – people loitering, sleeping, and defecating on the ramps.

Culver’s plan sounds like a reasonable technocrat-approved solution.  However, the solution gets volatile when you add people.  

Steve Doyle of The Huntsville Times wrote “Northwoods public housing residents reject fence along University Drive to deter jaywalkers”:

It was clear from the outset of Tuesday’s meeting that Culver’s plan was in trouble. One Northwoods resident said a fence gives the appearance that the city is “trying to imprison us.”

Another woman distributed a flyer with a picture of jail bars and the caption, “Do you know what the City of Huntsville has in store for your neighborhood?”

The Rev. Al Garrett with Interfaith Mission Service suggested Huntsville police conduct a safety campaign to educate children in Northwoods about the dangers of jaywalking on University Drive.

The city should also encourage construction of a convenience store on the Northwoods side of University, Garrett said, so residents won’t have to cross the busy road to shop at Chevron or Jet-Pep.

An exasperated Culver replied to the flyer “we are not here to lock folks up” and addressed (with HPD Chief Hudson, Fire Chief Sublett, and HEMSI Chief Webster) each of the claims made on the flyer:

- Do you want to be FENCED in?
- There will ONLY be ONE way in and ONE way out!
- Do you want to be bothered by heavy traffic AND noise?
- Do you want to be DENIED access to University Drive?
- How will POLICE, FIRE, or AMBULANCE get to you?

The audience politely listended to Culver’s presentation, and the Q&A was spirited but at one point out of control.  Imagine a heated Chaffee or Blossomwood meeting and turn up the volume, add some colloquial expressions and some arm-waving, and you get the idea.  People care about schools, roads, and crime.

Many residents want AAA school moved out to reduce traffic, objecting to “people busing in children from other neighborhoods” – Cavalry Hill school should be for “our kids”.

Residents also brought up the revised FEMA Flood maps, noting that several residents are disabled and without transportation.  This is a great point – does the HHA have a plan to evacuate disabled residents?  Does the City have a plan for all residents?

A representative of the Bicycle Advisory Committee cited a Federal Transportation Authority Pedestrian Safety Report (link to PDF), which recommends several “treatments” to improve pedestrian (and bicycle) safety.  She suggested a median similar to Governors Drive (between the Parkway and Triana), which would give pedestrians a safe zone while crossing seven lanes of traffic.

One resident asked HPD to watch for little kids crossing University and “take them home and arrest the parents”. Sgt Mark Roberts said that the HPD does pick up kids, but often there are no parents at home.

The lack of convenient shopping in the neighborhood was mentioned as contributing to the need to cross University Drive, as well as students walking to Butler High School.  Culver and Lundy said that they are looking at ways to bring in shopping.

Reverend Garrett made some good points, saying that it’s “important for the Police and the Council to exhaust all approaches”, suggesting a safety campaign and outreach to the two churches and AAA school.

The residents voted on Culver’s plan, and soundly rejected it (50 to 7).  Culver closed the meeting, saying: “You have spoken, I have heard, there is no fence”

…for the caged bird sings of freedom.
- Maya Angelou

Educate them

Me and several of my stereotypically ugly rancorous prejudiced nasty fellow citizens attended the Huntsville City Council working session tonight, where we were harangued by a sanctimonious ‘Fair Housing’ agitator.

City Councilman Will Culver arranged for Fair Housing ‘experts’ to address a working meeting of the Huntsville City Council, including George Jones of the Fair Housing Center of North Alabama (the group that threatened to sue the City over the Drummond Road house).   Jones launched into a thinly-disguised sales pitch for education programs and other services.  In my opinion he and his group are hustlers trying to shake down the City by threatening lawsuits with one hand and offering services with the other.

Jones said he “respects the opposition”, even as he uses phrases like “unfortunately”, “acrimony”, “rancorous”, “real ugly”, “nasty”, and the “heavy tinge of hostility”.  He presented his opinions as “very important” (many times) and his approach to opposing views was to “educate them” (I don’t think he realized that he was in a room with people who are ‘educated’ on housing issues).

The meeting ended prematurely because of the tornado – it passed over City Hall shaking the building – we evacuated to the basement after it passed.

City Councilman Sandra Moon was visibly agitated by Jones’ remarks, but she didn’t get to publicly respond to Jones.  If that guy comes back Moon is ready to ‘educate’ him on housing issues.

Several people approached Jones after the meeting was cancelled to discuss housing and his offensive mischaracterizations.  One questioner (and frequent commenter here) kept getting the same response from Jones regardless of his question:  Jones kept repeating “what have you done to further fair housing?”  Like paying for it doesn’t count…

Jones cited the Westchester case (“Housing as Busing”) in his speech as a reason to comply (or else!) with Fair Housing law.  Note that the Westchester case actually arose from “false claims” made by the County in its ‘Affirmatively Furthered Fair Housing’ certifications – so as long as the City of Huntsville doesn’t lie on forms sent to the Feds – they should be OK. 

Since I’m not a lawyer, my legal intepretation might be a bit shaky.  But since Mr. Jones is a “non-practicing lawyer” employed by a  lawsuit-happy “private non-profit”, his legal interpretation might be a bit shaky too.

I know that Councilman Culver had good intentions when he asked Jones to speak, but Jones is an agitator and he cares nothing about this City.  The other guest Culver invited, Michael Brown of Bradley Arant law firm in Birmingham, made a nice presentation about Fair Housing Law.  I understand that Culver wants to reschedule the meeting – maybe next time more “nasty” people from Huntsville will show up.  IMO Culver is doing the right thing by facilitating discussion of the housing issue, but if that guy represents the other side then nothing good can come of it.


Thanks to Mayor Battle, Deputy Mayor Rex Reynolds, and HPD Sergeant Mark Roberts for their response to the tornado – they reacted immediately and handled themselves professionally when notified.

Locally unwanted land use

I had a tough decision to make this evening: should I watch NCIS or the premiere of V (starring Morena Baccarin of Firefly fame)?

Well, instead of making the tough decision, I went to Dr. Richard Showers’ Huntsville City Council District One Town Meeting.  The main topic of the meeting was the City’s proposed “Correctional Center Zoning”, which will be voted on this Thursday night at the City Council meeting.  This issue doesn’t seem to have a good solution, so unfortunately the City Council must vote on the least bad solution – a real-life tough decision that weighs heavily on our elected officials.

Some background:  in February 2009 the City received a letter from a Federal Bureau of Prisons contractor (described by Mayor Tommy Battle as a “litigious group”) asking for guidance on locating a “residential re-entry center” or “correctional transitional housing” in Huntsville.  As of that date the clock stopped in a way (and started in another way).  According to City Attorneys, the City is required to allow public or private (contracted) correctional facilities and can only deal with zoning that was in place as of February 2009 (clock stop).  The City asked for and received two moratoriums in order to develop zoning ordinances for correctional facilities – but the deadline is December 23, 2009 (clock running).  Notable quotes: City Planner Marie Bostick – “we didn’t go looking for this”; City Administrator Rex Reynolds – “we need a managed response”; Mayor Battle – “let’s control it”.

The City Council votes Thursday to approve or disapprove the Zoning Ordinance proposed by the Planning Department and approved by the Planning Commission.  The Ordinance allows for development in large areas around the airport, close to the Toyota plant, and close to A&M in Chase (among other areas – see the maps at the link above).  No one wants a correctional facility 500 feet from their backyard (NIMBY – or as the hip kids call it, “locally unwanted land use”).  Councilman Will Culver announced tonight that he and Dr. Showers will both vote ‘No’ on the Ordinance.

If the Ordinance fails, it will take months to develop and approve another plan, during which time a correctional facility could be constructed pretty much anywhere in Huntsville.  Keep in mind that the proposed plan has been in the works since February – and that the City tried very hard to minimize the impact on residents – and that the City must develop broad guidelines that can withstand a legal challenge.

So these are the bad choices: vote Yes to zoning rules that will restrict the unwanted development to limited industrial areas, knowing that some people in the community will be harmed financially (and that their safety will be at risk) - or vote No and potentially expose the City to an unplanned facility (basically hoping that the City can come up with a better plan before the Bureau of Prisons acts).

It’s a tough decision – but that’s why our Mayor and City Council make the big bucks…  It’s also why elections matter.


Now let’s get into some meeting details and notes.  There were more than a dozen City officials in attendance: Mayor Battle, Councilmen Showers and Culver, City Administrator Reynolds, Police Chief Henry Reyes, Fire Chief Mike Sublett, Public Works Director Terry Hatfield, Community Development Director Michelle Jordan, and Assistant Planning Director Marie Bostick.

There were about 80 people or so in the crowd, including about 20 students from A&M’s Department of Urban Planning.  Stephanie Beecken of WAAY 31 reported on the meeting.

Public Works Director Hatfield said that he’s hired about 30 temps to help with curbside leaf pickup (it’s easier and better to mulch or compost your leaves).  Chief Sublett said that the Fire Department has 16 stations and is building a new station in Greenbrier (and could use about five more).  Chief Reyes said that 33 new cadets started at the Police Academy.  Community Development Director Jordan said that there will be a public hearing on the HUD Five Year Consolidated Plan Update (I missed the time – be on the lookout).

Councilman Showers said that he has “concern” for those who “worked real hard and saved their money to buy in that area” and that people “didn’t move to Carter Gin to be impacted by this type of situation”.

Councilman Culver made a point of saying that the zoning was “not racially motivated” and that he would like to see the zoning “proportionally distributed” around the City.  He noted that most of the available land was in his district near the airport, and that most of the residents in that area were white (he didn’t say white, but that’s what he said).

There were about 25 questions from the audience during the Q&A – bottom line – people don’t want it – other bottom line – “we can’t prohibit them” (Planner Lisa Aleddo). Another bottom line is that if you live in Madison County (or maybe even Madison) you don’t have the zoning protections – this only covers the City of Huntsville.

 The meeting wrapped up about 9PM and the City Planners stayed to answer all questions (including mine).  On the way out, I had the pleasure of speaking with Will Culver.  He took the time to explain to me his decision to vote against the Ordinance and details of the issue, which I truly appreciate.  From what I’ve seen, Culver is doing a great job as Councilman.

We’d all be sleeping together

“If North Korean missiles hit Huntsville, we’d all be sleeping together”.

I attended the Huntsville City Council meeting tonight, and Councilman Will Culver made a great point – Huntsville comes together.  This was better than TV’s “Parks and Recreation”;  if you haven’t attended local Government meetings you’re missing out on the real fun. Culver made his point that when disaster strikes or when people need help, it doesn’t matter what color you are, your neighbors are there for you.

Here’s a quicklook at the City Council meeting:

No more housing projects in South Huntsville.  Councilwoman Sandra Moon made it clear that the HHA Board had assured her that there will be no more apartment purchases in South Huntsville.  HHA Director Lundy reiterated that point saying “HHA has no intentions of purchasing apartment complexes in Southeast or Southwest Huntsville”.

Section 8 housing is OK.  It seems that a consensus of the City Government, HHA, and concerned citizens believe that vouchers and development (escrow) accounts are an acceptable approach to public housing in Huntsville.

The Medical District housing development is the ‘Gateway Place’ Senior Center, which will be built on the site of Councill Court.

HHA Director Mike Lundy does well in a controlled environment (i.e., Roberts Rules of Order).  He provided some good, detailed information to the public and his heart is in the right place.  As one of the leaders of Stone Manor who is being relocated said: “I feel that Mr. Lundy cares”. I might have some disagreements with him on policies, but I can’t help but feel pride that HHA is a “high-performing organization”.  I think it means that they spend money in a correct and timely manner, maybe someone will explain what it really means…

Mayor Battle proved himself to be an honorable gentleman. The Mayor apologized to Linda Lawrence for his remarks at the Chaffee Public Hearing, saying “I said some things I shouldn’t have said” and “I apologize to you”. Ms. Lawrence accepted his apology.

Councilman Culver said to people complaining about public housing: “keep it to yourself” and “we’re going to handle it”.  He’s new to the Council, but clearly he needs to get used to the idea of free speech.

People are dying trying to cross University Drive.  William Lynch spoke about his grand-daughter getting killed while crossing University.  He proposed a pedestrian crosswalk.

Councilman Richard Showers proposed an Ad Hoc Committee to study a Police Review Board.  He proposed a “diverse group” made up of representatives from the NAACP, other black groups he named but I forgot, Fraternities / Sororities (I don’t think he meant UAH), Public Housing, Existing Community Organizations, and the Homeless.  The Committee would review current police review board models and pick one.

More later… but it seems that the City and the HHA got the message.  IMO their public housing plan was too risky – the chance of failure is too great to risk the future of the City – at least that’s what I hope they think.

On a personal note, I got to meet Challen Stephens of The Huntsville Times. I have a lot of respect for his work, and I link to and quote from his articles often.  His articles on the links between income and test scores in City schools were well-researched and drew rational conclusions.  His recent article on the public housing issue was very good – he ended up validating many of the same points that were made here.

Even better, he says that he’s read Flashpoint.